A small mistake behind the wheel doesn’t automatically end an injury claim in Arkansas. The law compares each person’s role in the collision, then reduces or bars recovery based on the percentage of fault assigned. Those percentages can swing the value of a claim by tens of thousands of dollars.
That distinction matters after a crash in Jonesboro, especially when an insurance company points to speeding, a missed signal, distraction, or another alleged mistake. An early allegation of shared blame isn’t the final word, but the evidence supporting or undermining that allegation can substantially affect what an injured person recovers.
At Wells & Wells, we guide injured people through difficult questions about responsibility, injuries, and insurance coverage. We also offer flexible home and hospital appointments when travel is difficult after a collision.
How Comparative Fault Works in Arkansas Car Accident Claims
Arkansas follows a modified comparative fault rule under Arkansas Code § 16-64-122. The statute compares an injured person’s fault with the fault of the party or parties from whom they seek damages, then adjusts recovery accordingly.
If the injured driver’s share of fault is less than the opposing side’s, that driver can still seek damages, but the award is reduced by their fault percentage. The dividing line is 50 percent. A driver assigned 49 percent fault may recover reduced damages; a driver assigned 50 percent fault can’t recover from the other driver because their fault equals the opposing party’s.
The analysis also turns on proximate cause, a legally significant connection between conduct and the injuries claimed. A driver may have been slightly over the speed limit, for example, while the evidence still shows that another motorist’s unsafe turn actually caused the collision. That distinction can make or break a claim.
How Fault Percentages Change What a Claim Is Worth
Fault percentages directly reduce the damages an injured person can receive, including medical expenses, lost wages, and other losses supported by the evidence. Using a total damages figure of $100,000, here’s how the math plays out:
- Ten Percent Fault: A driver assigned 10 percent fault could seek $90,000 after a $10,000 reduction.
- Thirty Percent Fault: A driver assigned 30 percent fault could seek $70,000 after a $30,000 reduction.
- Forty-Nine Percent Fault: A driver assigned 49 percent fault could seek $51,000 after a $49,000 reduction.
- Fifty Percent Fault: A driver assigned 50 percent fault is barred from recovery against the equally at-fault opposing driver.
- More Than Fifty Percent Fault: A driver assigned 60 percent fault is also barred from recovery against the less-faulty opposing driver.
A few percentage points can determine whether a claim pays out at all. An insurance adjuster may assign a preliminary percentage during settlement discussions, but that position isn’t a court ruling. A judge or jury makes the final fault determination if the case goes to litigation, and any proposed settlement reduction can be challenged with evidence and a fuller account of how the crash occurred.
What Evidence Can Shift the Fault Percentage
Fault arguments are only as strong as the facts behind them. After a collision in Jonesboro, useful evidence may come from several sources:
- Crash Scene Photographs: Images can document vehicle positions, debris, skid marks, traffic controls, weather, and visible injuries.
- Vehicle Damage: Damage patterns may help show the angle and force of impact.
- Witness Accounts: Independent witnesses may provide information about traffic signals, lane movements, speed, or driver behavior.
- Traffic Citations and Reports: A citation or police report can be significant, though it doesn’t always resolve every factual dispute.
- Available Video: Dash camera footage, nearby surveillance video, or other recordings can disappear quickly if they aren’t preserved.
- Roadway Evidence: Photographs of signs, lane markings, sightlines, and road conditions matter most before the physical scene changes.
Medical records serve a different purpose. They connect the crash to treatment, physical limitations, and expenses, but they don’t independently establish who caused the collision. They’re still important when an insurer disputes the severity or timing of an injury.
Common comparative fault allegations include distracted driving, failure to keep a proper lookout, unsafe lane changes, delayed braking, and speeding. Each allegation should be evaluated against the full record, not accepted simply because it appears in an insurer’s letter or a recorded statement.
When More Than One Party Shares Fault
A crash doesn’t always come down to two drivers with competing versions of events. Arkansas law can require a comparison of fault among multiple parties whose conduct contributed to the harm, including another driver, a vehicle owner, an employer connected to a work-related trip, or a commercial carrier.
More vehicles don’t automatically mean more legally responsible parties. The central question remains whether a person or entity’s conduct was a proximate cause of the harm, which requires examining the available evidence, the relationships involved, and the sequence of events leading to impact.
This broader analysis becomes especially important when one insurer tries to place most of the blame on an injured driver while other contributors haven’t been fully investigated. Our car accident attorneys can review whether the facts support the percentage being asserted and whether additional responsible parties should be evaluated.
What to Do If an Insurer Blames You for the Crash
Don’t assume an insurer’s first fault assessment is accurate or permanent. Preserve information early. A disputed liability percentage becomes harder to challenge after vehicles are repaired, video is erased, or witnesses become difficult to locate.
Useful records to keep:
- Photographs and Video: Save original crash scene images, vehicle photos, and any available recordings.
- Contact Information: Keep names and phone numbers for witnesses, responding officers, and other involved parties.
- Reports and Communications: Retain police reports, insurance letters, claim numbers, emails, and text messages.
- Medical Documentation: Keep treatment records, bills, prescriptions, work restrictions, and documentation of missed work.
- Repair Information: Save estimates, invoices, towing records, and photographs taken before repairs.
Be careful about guessing why the crash happened or agreeing with a broad characterization of fault before the relevant evidence has been reviewed. A recorded statement can become part of an insurer’s claim file, and an incomplete description made immediately after a collision may not reflect what later evidence shows.
Our car accident attorneys can assess the evidence, the claimed injuries, and the arguments the insurer is raising. Prompt review also helps identify time-sensitive issues, including the statute of limitations, the deadline for filing a lawsuit, which can vary depending on the nature of the claim and the parties involved.
Shared Fault Doesn’t Always End a Claim
Partial responsibility doesn’t automatically bar recovery. Under Arkansas’s modified comparative fault rule, the percentage assigned to each party and the evidence behind it determines whether damages are reduced or eliminated entirely. That percentage is worth fighting over.
When fault is disputed after a collision in Jonesboro, Wells & Wells offers a free consultation to discuss how these principles apply to your specific situation. To get started, contact Wells & Wells at (870) 782-4084.